E15 weekly 17. 10.
E15 weekly 17. 10.
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/Monday, 17 October 2016
Issue 135 l newsstand price CZK 24/¤ 1 l www.e15.cz
Citizen Havel
Photos and anecdotes capture
the late playwright president
before and after he ascended
to the Castle
TOP STORY pages 8–11
Tickled by ivories
A decade ago rivals saw piano maker
Petrof as done for. But it wasn’t so
FACE TO FACE pages 10–11
9 771803 454314 0 0 1 3 5
Jan Stuchlík
Worldwide sales of 3D
printers for the produc-
tion of metal parts are
growing at an annual
clip of tens of percent. South Bohemi-
a’s Kovosvit MAS will in 2017 jump on
the accelerating bandwagon thanks to
new era equipment developed in a link-
-up with experts at Prague’s Czech
Technical University [ČVUT]. Its new
machines are capable of standard cast
milling, enabling the welding of metals
withthe3Dprintingmethod.Thecom-
pany, based in Sezimovo Ústí, South
Bohemia, is promising to cut costs by
two-thirds by using the technology in-
stead of the direct metal laser sintering
using powdered metal that is utilised
by competitors.
Continues on page 4
Machine tools maker Kovosvit MAS is
primed to "join the future" by becoming
one of the world’s 60 or so 3D metal
printing equipment producers
Czech
engineers
set for 3D
revolution
Photo: Profimedia.cz
facebook.com/
e15weekly
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/PRAGUE
Jan Šindelář
The wheels have come off
Italian company Grandi
Stazioni’s plan to finish
the reconstruction of Prague’s
Hlavní nádraží [Main Railway
Station]. As anticipated by E15
daily a fortnight ago, the Rai-
lway Infrastructure Admini-
stration [SŽDC] is ending its
contractual relationship with
the company after assessing
recommendations received
from its lawyers and the Office
for the Protection of Compe-
tition [ÚOHS]. “The contract
will terminate on 16 October
2016 with the expiration of its
primary duration,” said SŽDC
spokesperson Kateřina Šubo-
vá.
Rail officials have already
asked Grandi Stazioni to hand
over the “subject of lease” in
connection with the impen-
ding expiration of the contract,
shattering the company’s who-
le business plan devised for
the Czech Republic. The firm
had hoped to generate revenue
from maintaining the railway
station for the next 30 years.
However, it failed to complete
the building’s reconstruction
and even requested another
two years to refurbish the old
“Fanta” building. Any such
extension would require an
amendment to the original
contract, something SŽDC
says is not only out of the
question but is also apparent-
ly against the law. “We have in
place all the measures nece-
ssary for a smooth handover
of the railway buildings from
Grandi Stazioni to SŽDC
with zero interruption to the
railway station’s operations,
including all services provided
there,” added Šubová.
SŽDC plans to strike deals
with all merchants who cu-
rrently lease premises within
the station. Grandi Stazioni
confirmed it had received no-
news
2/3
Italians hit the buffers at Main Station
Grandi Stazioni’s plea for more time to finish reconstruction refused
Photo: Profimedia.cz
David Vagaday
Unstable subsoil continues
pose issues for the D8 motor-
way that connects Prague to
the north of the country. This
time difficulties have cropped
up with a road section near
Prackovice nad Labem, im-
mediately adjacent to the se-
ction that was buried under
a landslide. As long as the
problems are deemed to place
traffic safety in jeopardy, the
commissioning of the section
will have to be delayed.
The latest intended com-
missioning date is 17 Decem-
ber. “Nobody will be allowed
through to there unless the
motorway is 100-percent
safe,” said transport minis-
ter Dan Ťok (ANO). Despite
Ťok’s statement, his ministry
is sticking, for the time being,
with the newest set date while
working in tandem with the
Road and Motorway Directo-
rate [ŘSD] to find a solution.
The D8 motorway, meant
as a link running from Pra-
gue to Ústí nad Labem and
through to Germany, has
been plagued by unstable
subsoil for quite some time.
Following heavy rainfall, there
was a landslide in June 2013
near Litochovice in the Lito-
měřice region. The landslip
buried about 200 metres of
the motorway and damaged
nearby railway tracks. In the
words of Miroslava Pošvářová,
director of the “Shadow Road
and Motorway Directorate”,
the threat of a new landslide
is not exactly anything that
should surprise. “There have
been countless warnings in
previous months and years
regarding subsoil instability
affecting the three-kilomet-
re section, including a bridge
abutment at one end of this
section. Given the risk of sli-
pping soil, the foundations of
the bridge are quite unsatis-
factory as the stilts are too
short,” said the head of the
nonprofit organisation foun-
ded by transport entrepre-
neur Radim Jančura.
Planetarians present the 8-million pixel Starvid
Planetarium Prague has opened a modernised auditorium named Starvid. It enjoys a new
projection system acquired and installed at a cost of more than four million crowns. Images are
projected with the benefit of eight million pixels, which provides a definition that is more than
four times that of the previous used technology. The planetarium, located in Stromovka park, is
one of the largest in the world, with a projection dome of 23.5 m. The dome of the world’s largest
planetarium, in Japan, measures 35 m. Pictured is a moment from the How to Make a Comet show
presented to demonstrate the improved auditorium experience
Photo: ČTK
tice to quit. But the Italians
continue to claim that nego-
tiations are still ongoing with
no definitive decision taken
as yet. That seems to indicate
that the parting might be less
than amicable. Grandi Stazi-
oni rejects any other option
than continued cooperation.
Company secretary Andrea
Odoardi has threatened SŽDC
with litigation. Two weeks ago,
he said his company would
demand compensation not
only for the CZK 1.2bn it had
already invested in the stati-
on but for further billions of
crowns in damages. SŽDC on
the other hand points to how
Grandi Stazioni had not only
had enough time to complete
the reconstruction, but had
already been granted one de-
adline extension to finish it.
D8 subsoil issues
surface once more
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/Jan Šindelář
Lastyearproduceda milestone
for the railways as for the first
time ever over 12 months more
than 20 million passengers
took the train to the capital.
That marked growth of seven
percent year on year. The stati-
stics also showed that over five
yearsthenumberofpassengers
fromsomeregionsgoingbyrail
to Prague more than doubled.
“The roads, particularly in
the direction to Prague, are
overloaded and the problem
is not only the difficulty of
getting into the city, but also
parking. Therefore the growth
in mobility is making itself felt
there where there is capacity,
consequently on the railways,”
said transport expert and head
of the Association of Public
Transport Passengers [SCVD]
Miroslav Vyka. According to
Vyka, many more factors are
at play in causing the switch to
trains, such as the introduction
ofWi-Ficonnectionsandpower
sockets in carriages and impro-
vements in the quality of trains
Photo: Vectron
Prague festive markets tender not without controversy
Previous provider Taiko has won the tender to run the Christmas and Easter markets in Prague.
The firm is connected by some media to controversial Prague lobbyist Roman Janoušek, who
in 2014 was jailed for a hit and run. The results of the tender were approved by the City Hall
council led by Mayor of Prague Adriana Krnáčová (ANO). The winner will be contracted to
annually pay CZK 4m for leasing market settings in Old Town Square and Wenceslas Square.
The Zahrada Čech firm, owned by the Litoměřice municipality, offered to pay CZK 6m, but it was
excluded from the selection. No reasons for the move were given
Passengers packing
trains to Prague
Photo: ČTK
Hemmed in
Chopper chase
It was a year ago that
a diesel-powered Audi 8
stopped in front of the
European Commission
building. New Volkswagen
chief Herbert Diss stepped
out and told Elżbieta
Bieńkowska, commissioner
for industry: “We made
a mistake, we’ll fix the
damage.” Now the situation
has changed. Diss is in
constant contac with Brussels,
where Czech Věra Jourová
– the justice, consumer and
gender equality commissioner
– now stands at Bieńkowska’s
side. Both women are asking
more of the German carmaker
han it would like: VW must
compensate for damages as
well as take steps to regain
the trust of consumers.
That amounts to more than
simply updating emissions
software – it also ranges to
billions of crowns to be spent
in production investments
and compensation for drivers
in Europe. The Commission
now has in its hands a plan to
repair the doctored vehicles.
Jourová has welcomed
that, but conditionally. “It
is a start. We are far from
the end of this process.” Her
words serve as a warning
that the EU’s executive body
is insisting on compensation
for damages. For VW, it may
mean facing up to an even
harder reality. Only last week,
its works council chief said
the firm could cut 25,000
staff over the next decade as
older workers retire. VW, it
seems, may be in a battle for
its very survival.
The success of a Slovak
company ATE in a tender to
run air-based emergency
services in the Olomouc
region has led to legal
action from rival bidder
DSA. The latter firm is
seeking a thorough analysis
of technical points in the
tender. The Czech armed
forces need not be bothered
by such trifles as tenders.
For years, the military have
also been transporting
patients by helicopter,
although its heavy choppers
are unable to land at many
hospital heliports. Perhaps
because of that they have
been rewarded by the
chance of operating three
instead of two such stations.
Crimea is “closer” to
Russia! So say Russian
scientists, who have
observed that each year the
annexed peninsula moves
three millimetres closer
into the arms of Mother
Russia. Of course it is
purely coincidental that the
measurements began to be
recorded only after Crimea
was taken from Ukraine in
2014.
Prague Castle authorities
have built a wooden roof
so as to prevent tourists
waiting to have their
possessions searched by
security staff from getting
wet. Yes, such checks are
pointless, but it is nice to
know that the president
is taking into account the
ordinary folks’ feelings. But
there is a catch – the roof is
only 2x4 metres, and in the
event of rain can just about
only provide shelter to the
police conducting security
checks.
andservices,allofwhichenables
travellers to make active use of
their journey time.
“Growth in transport is
reproducing on the railways,
which have big potential, given
the substantial modernising of
infrastructure,fastertrainsand
theintroductionofmoderntrain
units,”saidCzechRailways[ČD]
spokesman Petr Šťáhlavský.
Vyka added: “When we also
look at the fact that people in
this country do not like moving
home for work purposes then
commuting can be the sole
choicewhenyouwanttoremain
living in the same place and si-
multaneously want interesting
employment with correspon-
ding remuneration.”
The statistics show the bi-
ggest train travel growth in
Moravia. For instance, the
number of passenger journeys
from South Moravia to Prague
last year jumped around a fifth
to 543,000. Five years ago,
the total stood at less than half
that.Vykamostlyattributedthe
change to the introduction of
modern Railjet trains and the
“dug-up”stateofswathesofthe
D1 motorway.
Igor Záruba’s notebook
Štěpán Bruner’s notebook
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/business & markets
4/5
BANKING
Jaroslav Bukovský
The crown could stren-
gthen to below 27 to
the euro during the
first days of 2017. The predic-
tion flows from three-month
crown-to-euro exchange
rate projections linked to
forwards which companies
and financial institutions are
using to plan future transac-
tions.
According to Thomson
Reuters data, for the first
half of January next year the
market is assuming a rate of
CZK 26.93/EUR 1. Some cu-
rrency speculators are coun-
ting with the Czech National
Bank [ČNB] releasing its grip
on the crown before the end
of the first quarter of 2017,
which they see as possibly in
line with its current commen-
tary.
“Perceptions of the short-
-term course of the crown
have changed since the last
meeting of the ČNB board. In
short, people on the market
have interpreted the words of
the central bank as offering
the possibility of an earlier
than to now expected end to
its exchange rate commit-
ment,” said Deloitte chief
economist David Marek.
The movement in the
market betting is according
to economists down to com-
munications from the ČNB
that it could free the crown
even before the attainment of
the sought-after two percent
tempo in prices growth. “Part
of the market has started to
bet on the fall of the crown
commitment, for example,
under the impact of strong
speculative activity,” said
Komerční banka economist
Marek Dřímal. Substantial
activity has been in evidence
during recent weeks.
In order to fend off stren-
gthening in the crown rate,
the ČNB during September
had to spend around 70 bil-
lion crowns on interventions,
Generali Investments estima-
ted. That would amount to
the third highest such mon-
thly expenditure by the cen-
tral bank in defence of the
weak crown since it started
interventions in November
2013. In all, the ČNB has put
in around CZK 700bn.
If the bank continued to
manage the exchange value
until the second quarter of
2017, in accordance with
what it has publicly stated,
the bill would substantially
rise. Economists expect the
speculators to intensify their
activity.
It is anticipated that once
the crown policy is shed, the
currency will greatly stren-
gthen, moving to a robust
level of 24 or 25 to the euro,
if the Czech Banking Associ-
ation’s assessment is proved
correct.
Crown speculators bet on new year clout
Market movers see a shift to 26.93 per euro
Drinks group
raises glass
to a future
without
spirits
Bohemia Sekt has
set out how from
now on it wants
to concentrate
exclusively on
producing sparkling
and still wines. It
is ridding itself of
its spirits business,
which includes brands
such as Pražská
vodka, Nordic Ice
and Dynybyl. The
company has sold its
distillery unit to Stock
Spirits Group for an
undisclosed price.
The acquirer owns
brands such as Pilsen’s
Božkov
Photo: Michael Tomeš
Continued from page 1
Kovosvit is entering a market
said to have very promising
prospects. Although last year,
world sales of industrial 3D
printers only amounted to
nearly four hundred, that
represented year on year
growth of 51 percent, accor-
ding to advisory firm Context.
Most of the sold printers went
to customers in Western Eu-
rope. International turnover
of the 3D printing market,
including printing works pro-
ducing 3D plastic printing,
amounts to around five billi-
on dollars annually, the latest
Wohler’s Report estimated.
It anticipated USD 25bn by
2021.
3D metal printing, yet to be
seen in Czech industry, often
produces items such as air-
craft engine parts or turbines
for power plants. “It is main-
ly used for the production of
prototypes. This country is
substantially lagging behind
in metal additive manufactu-
ring [another name for 3D
metal printing –Ed.] of metal
components, which is appa-
rently the fastest developing
sphere in 3D printing,” said
Petr Knap, managing partner
at the Czech branch of con-
sulting and advisory firm EY.
With the advantage of 3D
printing technology it is po-
ssible to manufacture com-
ponents which you could not
achieve with classic machi-
ning. Less consumption of
materials is required in 3D
printers’ production of parts,
making manufactured items
lighter and thus cheaper. In-
dustry observers often refer
to benefits seen in the moul-
ding of casts for the pressing
of plastics. Thanks to 3D
printing, it is possible to make
complex duct structures, used
to cool the moulds and pre-
ssed parts. This speeds up the
pressing.
Read more at e15.cz/weekly
Czech engineers set
for 3D revolution
Photo: ČTK
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/Jan Stuchlík
Electricity supplier Česká
energie has been pulled under
by the extravagant plans of
energy entrepreneur Ladislav
Dráb. Česká energie, a mem-
ber of Dráb’s CE Group, has
stopped supplying electricity
and gas to its 7,000 customers.
As a safety measure, supplies
to households have been taken
over by dominant players in
the respective regions, such
as ČEZ Prodej, E.On, Inno-
gy, Pražská plynárenská and
Pražská energetika.
Businesses were required
to secure contracts with new
suppliers by the morning
of 10 October. “I am quite
sure all customers of Česká
energie received attractive
offers from other suppliers.
A supplier’s collapse like this
is an opportunity for others
to snap up new customers,”
said Jiří Gavor, executive di-
rector of the Association of
Independent Energy Supp-
liers [ANDE]. Česká energie
had fallen behind with its
payments to ČEZ Distribu-
Energy supplier owned
by mysterious Dráb folds
Printscreen: bwin
up and down
Ivan Bednárik
Board chairman, ČD Cargo
The last new Vectron locomotive from Siemens
Mobility has arrived at a ČD Cargo depot. The
operator wants to use the engines to stren-
gthen its position on the long-haul market.
Boo-Keun Yoon
CEO, Samsung Electronics
The company’s engineers thought they had the
‘firebug’ smartphones problem sussed. They
didn’t. Adjusted Galaxy Note 7s kept overhe-
ating. The flagship phone was then scrapped.
Consumers have even been given special boxes
and gloves for use in responding to the recall.
Evžen Korec
Owner, Ekospol
Prague’s Ekocity Hostivař project, designed
to revive a moribund brownfield site, got the
green light from councillors. Ekospol can now
build hundreds of apartments at the location.
Oto Košta
General practitioner
In many regions, parties have scrambled to
elect coalitions against election winner ANO
– in Olomouc, however, winning local ANO mo-
vement leader Košta, a popular doc, is already
assured of becoming governor.
Angela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
The German state has taken on responsibility
for the liquidation of spent nuclear fuel. But
utilities will have to stump up billions of euros
to free them from nuclear waste storage liabi-
lities. Germany decided to pull the plug on its
60-year-old nuclear industry in 2011.
Betting firms assess the odds of action
against offshore market players
The game might be up for some of those foreign companies who run Czech-language internet
pages from offshore locations such as Cyprus or Gibraltar. International betting firms are consi-
dering the merits of becoming ‘upright business citizens’ with an official presence on the Czech
market. Amended legislation regulating gambling will from January 2017 require online fixed-
-odds betting and casino operators to seek a Czech commercial licence and commence paying
levied taxes. The state wants to block the websites of enterprises that don’t comply
ce for energy distribution
services. “Despite numerous
negotiations the debt kept on
growing leaving us with no
other option than to termina-
te our service contract with
the company,” said Roman
Gazdík, a spokesperson for
ČEZ Distribuce. This was
also the immediate cause of
why Česká energie ceased to
supply electricity in those re-
gions where distribution is in
the hands of ČEZ Distribuce.
E15 daily was unable to
obtain a response from Čes-
ká energie, which amassed
a loss of CZK 16.5m last year.
Various market sources su-
ggested that the downfall of
the supplier was the result of
Dráb’s failure to see through
his plans to build a gas storage
facility in the Vysočina regi-
on. GSCeP, a sister company
to Česká energie, which was
supposed to build the facili-
ty, went into bankruptcy in
May. Its debts include CZK
12m owed to Česká energie.
E15 weekly, economic and business news magazine | www.e15.cz
Igor Záruba, Executive Editor, igor.zaruba@cninvest.cz; Marian Hronek, Editor,
marian.hronek@cninvest.cz | Translation: TextMasters, textmasters@textmasters.cz
Contact: Adéla Nová, Secretary | Call (+420) 225 977 668
Postal address: Komunardů 1584/42, 170 00 Praha 7 | Published CN Invest a. s.,
Pařížská 130/26, 110 00 Praha 1 Josefov, IČ 04312945
Advertising: Šárka Kamarýtová, Sales Manager, sarka.kamarytova@cncenter.cz
Production: vyroba@cninvest.cz | Distribution: distribuce@cninvest.cz
Registration: E 21420 E15 weekly, ISSN 2464-711X
Reprints & Permissions: The Publisher will consider requests for reprints
or any other reproduction | Printed by EUROPRINT a. s. facebook.com/ e15weekly
Josef Středula
Unions leader
An attempt at persuading the individual
parties to support pushing through paid
sick leave benefits failed at the first hurdle.
Ruling coalition partner ANO said No.
Photo: ČTK
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/The ANO par-
ty must now be
viewed as a stable
part of the Czech
political scene.
It’s perhaps not
quite an ordinary
party, but ANO is
no anomaly
It isn’t hard to label Andrej
Babiš and his ANO move-
ment as a very real dan-
ger to Czech democracy. One
can find plenty of evidence to
support the assertion. But, as
demonstrated by the regional
and Senate election results,
many voters are yet to reach
this conclusion. Miroslav Ka-
lousek – the loudest anti-Babiš
voice in politics – and his TOP
09 party had a terrible election.
Babiš had a pretty good one.
And so one has no choice but
to accept that Babiš is a stable
component of the political sce-
ne. ANO is perhaps not quite
an ordinary party, but it is no
malignant growth that can be
corrected with a simple surgi-
cal procedure. There again, one
should take note that Babiš’s
regional victory was hardly a
landslide. He evidently picked
up a few Social Democrat and
even Communist voters, the la-
tter registering a notable drop
in their old allegiance. However,
the election confirms ANO’s
ability to attract a wide array
of voters with its de-emphasis
on policy and asinine marketing
campaigns pledging to “make
things better” and “improve
things”. Nonetheless, one re-
gional ANO party pooper was
the Mayors and Independents
(STAN) party; meanwhile, the
Social Democrats enjoyed two
notable victories in the regions,
and the Christian Democrats
took Zlín region.
In fact, the results represent
another welcome step away
from the dangerously single-
-coloured election results that
swept the regions in 2004 [the
Civic Democrats won all but
one region –Ed.]. ANO won
in nine regions, and gained
around half a million votes.
When, in 2008, the Social De-
mocrats switched the regional
map from blue to orange, it won
more than a million votes. So
the trend for 2016 is a good one
– regional elections should not
chiefly be seen as referendums
on the government. Rather they
should serve as gauges of regi-
onal governments’ performan-
ces. Results such as Martin Půta
in Liberec (STAN, governor)
and Jiří Zimola (Social Demo-
crat, governor) in South Bohe-
mia, could suggest this year’s
contests fulfilled their correct
role to a greater degree than in
previous years.
Future regional campaig-
ning based merely on opposing
Babiš’s assault on democracy
thus appears foolhardy. On
a purely technical level, the
ANO chief could hardly want
a better result than the panic
just witnessed in the Hradec
Králové region. There, a has-
tily assembled “All against
Babiš” coalition was formed
within hours of the results. If
a few more regions acted this
foolishly – without even going
through the motions of coaliti-
on negotiations – Babiš would
barely have to lift a finger to be
assured of winning the next
general election.
What stronger indication of
“the establishment” preven-
ting new blood from entering
local politics could Babiš ask
for? And what better argu-
ment could he want to help to
peddle his “I’m the good guy
outsider under attack by the
establishment” nonsense? The
more such foolish knee-jerk
coalitions coming into being,
the greater will be his victo-
ry next year. Babiš’s soldiers
should be allowed to govern
in the regions – for better or
worse.
It is far better to let ANO
shoot itself in the foot throu-
gh governing, than to fuel its
narrative as the injured party
of real change. It is also ne-
cessary to try to find a way to
counter ANO’s national-level
popularity. There, playing the
“threat to democracy” card
may serve a useful purpose. Af-
ter all, parliamentary elections
have a very different character
than local ones – and ANO’s
nationwide 21.05 percent is
hardly cause for Babiš to be
popping the champagne corks.
opinion
6/7
joke
Stanislav Šulc’s diary
Humble
pie for Kalousek
Young voters don’t go to
the polls, something which
has apparently broken
the back of TOP 09. But
the real reasons for the
poor showing of this once
strong party in the regi-
onal elections are likely
more complicated – and
should serve as a warning
to its leaders.
Before the votes were
even in, TOP 09’s cha-
irman, MP Miroslav
Kalousek, tried to explain
away the poor showing
by saying the party’s base
voters didn’t turn out at
the polls. He included
young voters – those
who engaged in political
debate on social media,
but then failed to actually
vote. There is certainly
something to be said for
this non-voting phenome-
non, but it can hardly be
said to fully account for
the collapse of what was
once the Czech Republic’s
strongest right-of-centre
party.
Far more likely is that
TOP 09 may now be little
more than a Prague-cent-
ric bubble. So while Ka-
lousek and other notable
party members tried to
devote intense energies
to touring the regions,
they still failed to break
the lingering image of
the former pro-austerity
finance minister Kalousek
as a symbol of all that was
bad. In the regions, the
negative caricature still
resonates, as reflected
in both the billboards of
opponents, and also in
social media chatter.
But in Prague the picture
is very different. TOP 09 is
doing well in the capital,
and thanks to its success
there, it managed a de-
cent showing in the 2013
general election, despite
being a member of the lo-
sing government coalition
of the day. But the party
leadership has evident-
ly failed to grasp that
outside of Prague TOP 09
really is a party hovering
somewhere at around
five-percent of support.
So now Kalousek is thrust
into some obligatory
navel-gazing and eating of
humble pie. What happe-
ned to “HIS” voters? And,
more importantly, who
will pay for the party’s
poor results?
Photo: Anna Vacková
“When petty squabbles break out in the office,
call Sharon. She used to run a daycare center.“
Martin
Čaban
The election confirms
ANO’s ability to attract
a wide array of voters
Playing
into Babiš’s hands
255896/92 inzerce
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/POLITICS
opinions
interviews
NEWS
markets
business
the eCONOMY
the only english
language business weekly
in the czech republic
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/8/9
top story
The day of October 5 that recently passed would have
been Václav Havel’s 80th birthday. Photographs of the
late Czech president by Oldřich Škácha (who took most
of the pictures in the ensuing pages) capture Havel while
he was still a private citizen before November 1989. These
pictures are supplemented by a collection of testimonials
from Havel’s closest friends and associates sourced from the
upcoming book Náš Václav Havel [Our Václav Havel] by Jan
Dražan and Jan Pergler
1973: Havel helps out
during some repair work at
the villa of Pavel Kohout
l
the man who l
l
wouldn’t l
l
be king l
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/1950. Havel
pictured at 14
years-old, one
year before
he left middle
school
Hrádeček (a small village in northeastern Bohemia where Havel
owned a countryhouse –Ed.) became a crucial sanctuary for
Václav Havel. He bought the derelict property in 1967 for pea-
nuts and then set about undertaking renovations. That was during the
time when we both spent time there. His life involved being constantly
on edge, but while there he could afford to forget his woes. Suddenly
he was a slightly different person. This may surprise you, but the daily
schedule there was actually quite intensely structured. The mornings
were tough, with work taking place until noon; cooking then took place,
with lunches usually quite opulent. After that came a lazy afternoon, fo-
llowed by a rich evening schedule. The central feature of these evenings
were Vašek’s philosophical “tomes”, during which he managed to spend
two hours engaged in fantastic talk on a subject which we had chosen
together. And during these we had to drink at least one crate of his at-
rocious white wines – he liked wines along the lines of Poezie or Dievčie
hrozno... Anyway – then it all ended with a so-called effort to get back to
nature. That meant climbing naked among the trees in the old orchards
between Hrádeček and the house of Andrej Krob [Czech playwright
and director –Ed.]. And each visit started with singing, because Hráde-
ček had its own hymn – Massachusetts by the Bee Gees. Why this song,
I don’t exactly know. And so we had a really good time there.
Miroslav Masák, architect, advisor to Václav Havel
We went to tell Olga [Havel’s first wife –Ed.] that the Civic
Forum [OF, a pro-democracy umbrella organisation –Ed.)
would indeed be nominating him for president, and I wrote his
nomination text. And she really was upset. It certainly wasn’t prearran-
ged with her. And Olga said: “Absolutely not. Do you think that Vašek
could still go to Rybárna (a local restaurant near Havel’s Prague home
–Ed.) if he was up at the Castle? Guys, that Jaroslav Šabata [left-of-cen-
tre politician and philosopher –Ed.] would be good.” And so she then
seriously tried to present to us the idea of Jaroslav Šabata from Brno
and to argue that he would be a super president. So, I have to say, she
really wasn’t for the whole idea [of her husband being president].
Michal Horáček, journalist, author, lyricist
I didn’t meet him until the Tříska wedding [that of Czech-American
actor Jan Tříska and Karla Chadimová –Ed.] in 1968. My future
husband, Jan Němec [Czech film director –Ed.], was a distant cousin
of Václav. And so he took me along to the wedding, saying that he should
introduce me to Václav. Only later did my husband reveal that Havel
had actually wanted to meet me – and that had he, Jan, not gotten to me
first, then Václav would have had me as his girlfriend. I had no idea that
Václav Havel had any such ulterior motives. But that would not have
worked because from the moment Olga and I laid eyes on each other we
liked each other. So we ended up being a kind of trio. The truth is that
when I was divorcing Němec [in 1973 –Ed.], then I went and hid out at
the Havels’. It was an unusually long divorce given that we didn’t have
any children. And he [Havel] was making so many jokes along the lines
of: “But she was with a married man!” Of course he didn’t mention that
Olga had been there too. Němec then moved to the US, and when he
came back after the revolution, we all ended up spending time together
again.”
What were your impressions of Havel when you first met him?
“Like a teddy bear. A teddy bear! And I always referred to him as
Medvídek [Teddy]. But I would never dare call him that to his face: You
are a Teddy. That would be too much.”
Marta Kubišová, singer and Charter 77 signatory
He said he never wanted to be president, which is nonsense. He
did. The role changed him a lot. At the beginning, he believed
he would guide the state like Masaryk. That he would invite the
heads of the political parties for talks, and would appoint governments
according to his whims. He really did appoint the first ones in this ma-
nner, and he had considerable influence. But then later he did not. He
entirely lost his political influence. Which is why in 1998 people were
telling him not to run again, but I think it was a good thing that he did.
He still embodied a sense of moral authority. The nation – even though
his influence was diminishing – saw in him a kind of line in the sand that
could not be overstepped. As long as Havel was alive, then everything
would be fine.
Jan Ruml, politician
Photo: © Oldřich Škácha / knihovna Václava Havla
Photo: ČTK Photo: Profimedia.cz
The 1960s:
The playwright’s star
is on the rise. In 1963,
Divadlo Na zábradlí
performs his Zahradní
slavnost [The Garden
Party]; a year later he
marries first wife Olga
Šplíchalová
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/10/11
top story
Since we are on the subject of decent conduct, I will relay one more story. I was
chairman of the Senate, he was president, and we wanted to meet up in a pub
in Prague’s Malá Strana. I knew that I naturally could not leave the president
waiting for me. That is a kind of obsession of mine – I prefer to always go somewhere
early and be the one to wait. I arrived 10 minutes early, and he was already there! So
I became flustered as a result, and he saw that and apologised. Six months later we
held another meeting. I said to myself: I can’t have a repeat of last time, so I will come
20 minutes beforehand. So I arrived...and he was there again. And once again he apo-
logised. It was awful. But at the same time, one has to admire such decency and even
humility. He was the head of state, but he was already there so as to not risk coming
late... But perhaps that is not the best approach for power politics, as was later shown
in negotiations with Václav Klaus.
Petr Pithart, politician
The most beautiful day of my life was 29 December, 1989. That
was when Václav Havel was elected president. We emerged
from [St. Vitus Cathedral within Prague Castle] after the
Te Deum [mass] and we talked with friends and attendees. I was
popular because it was cold and I pulled out a hip flask from my
coat. Then suddenly the president’s secretary appeared and told me
I was invited to attend lunch. I felt truly honoured, but the ensuing
lunch was truly ghastly, because back then the Castle kitchen was
really abysmal. It was a working lunch, and everyone who was there
was given some tasks to carry out. And before I had a chance to
catch my breath suddenly I had been appointed as a Castle official.
Karel Schwarzenberg,
politician, chancellor to President Havel
1979: Havel is sentenced
to four-and-a-half years
of imprisonment for
illegal political activities.
His correspondence with
Olga is later published
as Dopisy Olze [Letters
to Olga]
Photo: ČTK
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/Taken from the magazine
We grew close very quickly. His term
leading the country was so unusual that
we would mostly end up meeting in the
pub. I remember one such meeting at the Vikarka
[a restaurant near the Castle –Ed.]. Václav was
sitting at the head of the table, and I was the only
one there from Slovakia. Next to me sat Jiří Křižan
[late Czech screenwriter –Ed.] and he had this kind
of large chequered paper with him, and on it was
written “Prime minister, minister of the interior...”
etc. The first post-revolution government was
being formed there and then.
Fedor Gál, politician, sociologist
As Dienstbier’s deputy [Jiří Dienstbier, first post-1989 non-communist foreign minister
–Ed.] in October 1990 I headed some talks in Warsaw and Havel called me up and
told me to hurry back to Prague. So that night I got into a car, and arrived back in
Prague in the morning. And Havel told me that he had decided that he had to fire Vacek
[General Miroslav Vacek, defence minister 1989-90 –Ed.], and that he wanted me in the post
instead. I was shocked as I had no idea he would be making such a request. But in any event,
I told myself: He has to know why he is making such decisions. I had some ties to the mili-
tary, and knew some generals... And he said: “So?” and I replied: “I need to think about it?”
And he asked: “How long do you need?” I said: “Two or three days, as this is no picnic. I have
to talk to the generals that I know, and find out the current situation.” And he said: “That
won’t work.” So I asked why, and he said: “Because I have to nominate you at 2pm.” So I said
to myself: “Well, if he is so determined, he must know what he is doing.” So I agreed.
Luboš Dobrovský, politician, diplomat, journalist
April 1975: Václav Havel writes an open letter
to Czechoslovak president Gustav Husák in the
Hradčany apartment of writer Pavel Kohout
Photo: Oldřich Škácha
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/12/13
face to face
Photos: E15 Michael Tomeš
ZUZANA CERALOVÁ PETROFOVÁ
Petrof may once more
strike a chord in America
Ten years ago,
Europe’s largest
piano maker,
Hradec Králové-based
Petrof, looked like it
might not survive a
60-percent collapse
in US-based sales. But
since then the business
has caught a second
wind, thanks, in part,
to new markets such as
China
Daniel Novák
You actively backed the Mayors and
Independents and Eastern Czechs co-
alition in October’s regional elections.
Why?
If something is going change, then it
has to start in the regions. The regions
have significant powers to improve our
national environment. Whether that
pertains to securing quality social and
health care, or to fixing broken stre-
ets, or to ensuring that our secondary
schools have sufficient teachers for all
subjects. All those are issues which are
of daily relevance to us.
Do you have any political ambitions
yourself?
As the Petrof family, we have never
been directly involved in politics, nor
do I have any such ambitions. But we
are happy to support smart, right-of-
-centre, and morally competent figures.
Shortly after arriving at Petrof in
2004, the company found itself facing
major problems as a result of a fall in
US customers. Was that a baptism of
fire?
Certainly. I am a pharmacologist by
background, and so I lacked experi-
ence. But I went into battle full steam
ahead, and it turned out well.
segment. But as a rule bankers can be
great visionaries. They understand
both macro and microeconomics, and
make great partners in that regard.
Did you then turn your back on the US
market?
Sadly, our partner there, who had
stabbed us in the back, and who had
caused me to have to cut the size of our
firm in half – and then half again – was
presenting us as “cheap goods from
Eastern Europe”. And so we had a bad
reputation in America. They liked us,
and our sales were good. But we were
selling goods at a price which we were
no longer prepared to accept. And after
the aforementioned bad experience,
we stated that we would only sell to
the US if the Americans paid upfront.
And we have stuck to that. Our sales
there aren’t huge. But at the same time,
when musical instruments leave here
for the US, they have always been pre-
paid. But one key development is that
the state-run CzechTrade agency has
named the US as a supported country
for next year.
What does that mean for you?
We are in talks about once again featu-
ring our products at a large American
musical instruments trade fair. The
[trade and industry] ministry would
help finance a display space. And in
relation to this we are also debating
whether the time has not arrived to
once again focus our attentions on the
US market. We will see what the mood
is like at the trade fair.
Petrof almost went under as a result
of the impact of the financial crisis in
the US. Do you not now face the same
risks associated with a strong reliance
on exports to China and Russia?
We are trying to avoid such a risk. [Shoe
firm founder Tomáš] Baťa once said that
a company should not be dependent on
one customer for more than 15 percent
of its revenues. And because China now
represents up to 35 percent of revenu-
es, we agreed that we need to diversify
to negate such a risk. So instead of one
partner there we now deal with four
paying partners in China. Furthermore,
these cover varying territories. Asides
from producing certain brands for the
What was the likelihood of failure in
restoring Petrof’s fortunes?
Quite large. Back then, at the point
when Petrof lost 60 percent of revenues
as a result of the US market, major
players in crisis management were
telling me that I had no chance. They
said that in reality the company was no
longer ours but belonged to the banks.
To which I responded that hope is the
last thing to die, and then I set about,
step by step, negotiating with the banks.
We persuaded them, and ultimately
they turned out to be partners. They
provided much useful guidance, and
also some advice which we fortunately
did not heed.
What advice from the banks did you
not follow?
They advised us to cease making
smaller upright pianos and only focus
on grand pianos, because they had the
best profit margin. And it is good that
we did not do that. Right now, upright
pianos represent our strongest sales
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/Zuzana Ceralová
Petrofová (48)
Fifth generation of the piano-
making Petrof family. Studied
at the Pharmacological Faculty
of Charles University in Hradec
Králové. Joined her namesake
company in 2000; took over the
management four years later.
Winner of the 2014 Manager of
the Year Award.
Chinese market outside of our own Pet-
rof, we also undertake licensing efforts
directly in China, and so have money
flowing in from various sources.
Do you face problems with plagiarised
goods?
We have a dedicated system which we
use to determine if an instrument is
genuine or a fake. Similarly to bank-
notes we have added a host of special
detectable elements which we use to
detect our products. Additionally, we
know most dealers in China, and so if
some instrument comes on the market
posing as a Petrof, which doesn’t seem
genuine, then we are immediately aler-
ted to that.
What about the situation in Russia?
Right now, Russia represents 12 percent
of revenues, but that figure used to be
higher. Even more than 20 percent. But
the political and economic situation re-
main not good there. People are frugal
because of the weak rouble, which has
been strongly reflected in private sales
of large musical instruments and in
school tenders.
How do you manage to get hold of qua-
lity wood?
Sadly the amount of available resonant
wood in the Czech Republic is falling,
because no-one is seeking to ensure
that new trees of this kind are planted.
Such trees only grow at 800 metres
above sea level. Additionally, they have
to be 80 or more years old. And it has to
Does that impact the sound of the in-
struments?
Yes. We undertook blinds tests, during
which we did not know from where
a resonant wood was sourced. We let
musicians try them out and evidently
a difference was noticed.
This year you added a parent compa-
ny above Petrof, namely Petrof Pianos
Group. Did that mean some sort of in-
ternal rearranging of the business wi-
thin the family?
When I became managing director of
the firm in 2004, I needed to have a
majority share in my hands so as to be
able to negotiate effectively on behalf
of the company. I came to an agreement
with most of my relatives and gained a
70 percent stake. The agreement was
such that once the company was stabi-
lised and consolidated, we would settle
among ourselves and I would return a
50 percent stake back to them. Now
that time has arrived. So together with
those that went along with the plan, I
created Petrof Pianos Group. I have a
51 percent stake, enabling me to run
the firm. This was a way to denote tho-
se of us with a common direction for
the firm, and who shared in the vision
which I am translating.
You took over the firm 12 years ago
from your father. Does he still have a
say in how you run things?
He serves as my advisor. Because eve-
rything has already happened once
before, then whenever I am at a loss
as to what to do, I go and see him and
he proverbially pours out a solution
from his sleeves. He is also of great
help in PR activities. Because he likes
to attend all kinds of concerts, and to
talk with pianists about whether all was
in order, if they are satisfied with our
customer service and so on. He attends
one or two concerts a week in this way,
which is very helpful to me. But as for
the actual running of the company, he
leaves that to me.
Have investors taken an interest in the
company?
Many competitors are unable to come
to terms with the complex conditions
in the market and are thus selling up to
Asian firms. The Koreans and Chinese
have also made advances in regard to
our firm. I heard them out so as to know
the kind of interest that exists in our
company. But each time we ended up
parting ways.
be a tree growing deep inside a forest,
in order to be spared the influence of
winds. Traditionally we used to source
wood from Vysočina and Šumava, but
now there are ever fewer of these re-
sources available. Meaning we have to
look elsewhere. In the Italian Dolomites
or on the other side of Šumava.
Just like with
banknotes we
have added a
host of special
detectable
elements which
we use to spot
counterfeits.
Our Chinese
dealers alert us
if an instrument
appears
to be a fake
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/food
14/15
Photo: Tomáš Lébr
Taken from the magazine
Migh how
those
irresistible
simple dishes we
love to scoff can
prove a real pitfall
in the kitchen. You
shall overcome!
At least where
poppy seed cones
are concerned.
With repetition,
you will master
that potato pastry
Jana Trundová
Boil the potatoes in their skins,
strain and leave to cool. After
peeling, finely grate into a bowl.
In a small bowl, mix the egg
yolks. Make a deep dimple in
the potato, pour in flour and
starch, as well as the yolks, and
half-work out the dough with
a stirringspoon.Then,withyour
hands, work it into a smooth soft
doughwhichwilleventuallyhold
for shaping, but will be suffici-
ently light to prevent the cones
from becoming stiff. From the
dough, you can now make 2 roly-
-poly pastries. Sprinkle starch
on your work surface and lightly
cover the roly-polies in it before
cutting them into small pieces.
With your hands roll the pieces
into cones the size of a finger.
Drop the cones into boiling
water. As soon as they surface
remove them with a perforated
ladle and place in a bowl.
Mix the poppy seed with sugar
and melt the butter. Divide the
cones into plate servings, pour
on the sweetened poppy seed
and coat with the melted butter.
For adults, you can add some
plum jam mixed in rum, or some
chopped and dried plums sou-
sed in rum the day before.
Poppy seed cones
4 SERVINGS
PREPARATION:
40 minutes + cooking
potatoes
900 g potatoes
(Czech classification: type B)
300 g coarse flour
1 heaped tbsp potato starch
+ layer for sprinkling cones
preparation surface
2 yolks
a little semolina
½ tsp salt
ground poppy seeds
icing sugar
100 g butter
Know your stuff
M
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/society
Photos: Michael Tomeš
Breakfast with PM launches E15
meetings & business brand
With the arrival of autumn, E15 daily started its E15 meetings & business program
of regular events and conferences featuring eminent guests. The first occasion, on
27 September, was Breakfast with Prime Minister Bohuslav Sobotka, held at Prague
restaurant Bellevue. The PM discussed current difficulties seen in enterprise, the
economy and politics with leading representatives of Czech business and important
institutions. Readers of E15 were able to watch the discussion in real time on E15.cz.
The moderator for the occasion was Reflex magazine commentator Bohumil Pečinka
(photo on the left). Among others involved in the conversation were former Czech
PM Mirek Topolánek, now a director at Slovakian gas transit operator Eustream, and
Libuše Šmuclerová, CEO at Czech News Center (photo below)
advertising
257504/108
Monday, 17 October 2016
Issue 135l newsstand price CZK 24/¤ 1l www.e15.cz
Citizen Havel
Photos and anecdotes capture
the late playwright president
before and after he ascended
to the Castle
TOP STORY pages 8–11
Tickled by ivories
A decade ago rivals saw piano maker Petrof as
done for. But it wasn’t so. Who’s laughing now?
FACE TO FACE pages 10–11
9 771803 454314 0 0 1 3 5
Jan Stuchlík
Worldwide sales of 3D
printers for the produc-
tion of metal parts are
growing at an annual
clip of tens of percent. South Bohemi-
a’s Kovosvit MAS will in 2017 jump on
the accelerating bandwagon thanks to
neweraequipmentdevelopedinalink-
-up with experts at Prague’s Czech
Technical University [ČVUT]. Its new
machines are capable of standard cast
milling, enabling the welding of metals
withthe3Dprintingmethod.Thecom-
pany, based in Sezimovo Ústí, South
Bohemia, is promising to cut costs by
two-thirds by using the technology in-
steadofthedirectmetallasersintering
using powdered metal that is utilised
by competitors.
Continues on page 4
Machine tools maker Kovosvit MAS is
primed to "join the future" by becoming
one of the world’s 60 or so 3D metal
printing equipment producers
facebook.com/
e15weekly
Czech
Engineers
set for 3D
revolution
Photo: Profimedia.cz
EW16101701A1.indd 1
14.10.2016 10:38:40
You can subscribe
securely via e-mail
Use the e-mail address
weekly@predplatne.cz,
State your name and delivery
address. Use the code WEEK 1016
as the message subject
You can also subscribe
online at our website
www.predplatne.cz
To subscribe on
a toll-free number,
call 800 248 248
Simply call to provide your
personal details and cite the
code WEEK 1016
Full-year subscription:
CZK 650 and as a gift
you will receive a voucher
worth CZK 1 000
The shopping voucher
can be used for the
product offers on
Friendly Suits website
www.friendlysuits.cz
until 30 June 2017.
Get your subscription!
This subscription offer is valid
until 30 October 2016
This offer is available to new subscribers only and will be extended while stocks last. In the event of stocks being exhausted, the publisher reserves the right to provide a substitute gift. Gifts are forwarded within six weeks from the date of the reception of the subscription payment. Subscribers
acknowledge that their subscription cannot be cancelled for a period of one year from the date of the subscription order being made. Subscribers further acknowledge that their subscription will be automatically extended for another subscription period unless they have expressed their
explicit wish to terminate their subscription by means of a written notification forwarded to the correspondence address of CN Invest a. s. at Komunardů 1584/42, 170 00 Praha 7. By placing a subscription order, subscribers express their assent with, and undertake to follow, these terms and
conditions of delivery. By placing a subscription order, subscribers also grant their consent to the publisher entering all the personal information they have provided (hereinafter “personal data”) into a database – with CN Invest a. s., seated at Pařížská 130/26, Josefov, 110 00 Praha 1, acting
as the administrator – and to the publisher subsequently using such personal data for the purposes of offering products and services as well as for the forwarding of commercial information via electronic and printed means in accordance with Act No. 480/2004 of the Czech legislative code.
Such consent is granted for an indefinite period, i.e. until it is revoked. Subscribers also grant their consent to the processing of personal data through third parties authorised by the administrator. Subscribers acknowledge their rights as stipulated in Sections 11 and 21 of Act No. 101/2000
of the Czech legislative code, on the protection of personal data, which in particular state that the provision of personal data is voluntary, that consent can be revoked at any time at no cost via the correspondence address of the administrator, that subscribers have the right to access their
personal data and to request its correction thereof, and rights to the blocking of incorrect personal data, the liquidation of personal data, etc. In case of any doubt regarding the compliance of the administrator in relation to such subscriber rights, a subscriber is entitled to bring their case to
the attention of the administrator or to directly approach the Office for the Protection of Personal Data [ÚOOÚ]. The offer is valid only for orders delivered within the territory of the Czech Republic.
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/16
diversions
Beware getting
the stink eye from
the Trifot
Rebel artist David Černý’s new
sculpture, the 12-metre-high
stainless steel walking Trifot,
stalks the new Czech Press
Photo Gallery in Prague’s Nové
Butovice. Somewhat inspired
by The Day of the Triffids, the
creature has a head made
of real-brand cameras. It
eyes passersby and displays
them on large screens. The
multi-genre art space features
photos by leading Czech and
foreign photographers as
well as streetart and video
installations. It has an archive
of pictures from the annual
Czech Press Photo competition
invitations
picture of the week
Photos: Archive
Photo: ČTK
TRIP TIP
Strahov
Monastery
This 12th century Prague
treasure includes the Strahov
Library with its Theological
Hall, graced with 1720s stucco
decoration and paintings, and
the magnificent interior of
the Philosophical Hall with its
grandiose ceiling fresco.
GIG
Swans, Divadlo
Archa
The legendary experimental
rock bank from New York bid
their ‘Swans-song’ farewell to
local fans with their last ever
Prague concert. The band
released 14th studio album The
Glowing Man in April. Young
Swedish singer Anna von Hau-
sswolff supports. 19 October.
CONCERT
Bugge
Wesseltoft
Prague’s Palác Akropolis on
25 October presents Bugge
Wesseltoft’s New Conception
of Jazz – 20 Year’s Celebration
Tour. The Norwegian jazz
musician, pianist, composer
and producer got known for
future jazz, or nu jazz.
EXHIBITION
Podzimková’s
Polojasno
Eliška Podzimková, an
endlessly creative young
multimedia artist with unique
wit and great technical skill,
presents Polojasno [Somewhat
Cloudy] at Prague’s Jindřišská
Věž until 20 November.
Chuckles are found in the
mundane.
CINEMA
Café Society
(2016)
A romantic comedy drama from
Woody Allen. It’s the 1930s and
a young Bronx native moves
to Hollywood where he falls
in love with the unpretentious
secretary of his powerful uncle,
a powerhouse talent agent. She
rebuffs his advances. Cinemas
everywhere.
About us. E15 Weekly is one of a group of business and economics-oriented publications printed by CN Invest a. s. It is a sister title to the E15 daily. Both
periodicals, as well as a number of others, came under new ownership in the spring of 2016 when part of a portfolio formerly published by Mladá fronta a. s.
was acquired. CN Invest a. s. publishes a broad range of print and online titles. In addition to other business-minded titles, the company also publishes lifestyle
and women’s magazines (Maminka, Dieta, Moje psychologie) and children’s titles (Mateřídouška, Sluníčko). The publishing house also enjoys a considerable
presence in the segment of technical and men’s online titles. CN Invest, and its sister company CZECH NEWS CENTER a. s. (the biggest publishing house in the
Czech Republic, with titles such as Blesk, Reflex, Svět motorů, ABC), are members of the media concern CZECH MEDIA INVEST a. s.
http://www.floowie.com/en/read/e15w-2016-10-17/